• Call Cognex Sales: 855-4-COGNEX (855-426-4639)
  • Contact us

Quality control and inspection for head-up displays

Quality control and inspection for head-up displays

Cognex ensures long-term customer satisfaction and cost-efficient quality control for BMW in Munich

BMW clients expect the best and demand the most accurate equipment when buying a car from the Munich based manufacturer. Increased demand for a “head-up display” (HUD), meant that BMW needed to find a quality control system for their HUDs. This system would need to cope with the speed of their production line while maintaining high safety standards.

Quality control for HUDs at the facilities of the automobile manufacturer BMW, is presently installed on the production-lines of the 5- and 6-series, and is an example of the most performing industrial image processing.

A new perspective for BMW drivers

The advantages of a HUD as an option in a car have created a rapid increase in demand. The HUD is a driver information device, developed and produced by Siemens VDO Automotive. The image-producing unit of the head-up display projects a virtual image onto the windscreen by means of an array of optical mirror systems. The displayed image is projected in the viewing field of the driver at a distance of about 2m. The driver can therefore perceive all important information regarding the vehicle and navigation within his normal field of viewing. In this way, the driver has optimal access to information with minimum disruption of concentration.

If the HUD is even slightly misaligned, this will interfere with the driver’s perception of the surrounding environment such as street markings, vertical lines of houses, or garage entry.

Image Quality: The decisive criterion

That is why the imaging quality of the projected display in the vehicle is the decisive criterion for acceptance of the HUD by the user. Automobile manufacturer BMW in Munich was concerned with the introduction of a head-up display as an optional equipment feature for the new car types of the 5- and 6-series. For this purpose, the department for Technical Integration at the Research- and Innovation Center of BMW in Munich needed a precise quality control suitable for industrial use. The fact that up to this point there was no appropriate quality control system based on image processing available meant the objective was to develop an absolutely new product within a very tight time frame.

A completely new solution

Measuring methods for the control of imaging quality of HUDs had previously been developed in the laboratory, but there was still a long way to go to reach a solution for the production process. These studies provided important target specifications for the preparation of the system design for this quality assurance project. To add to the technical constraints, this quality control system would have to cope with the interaction of the windscreen and the projection of the HUD installed in the vehicle. Even minor defects in a completely assembled vehicle would not be tolerated at the end of the assembly line.

On the basis of the system design specifications, BMW’s “Technical Integration”-division (hereafter referred to as “TI”) contacted several suppliers of machine vision systems seeking a solution based on image processing which would work with the required quality assurance system of the head-up display. In mid 2002, they decided to work with Gefasoft GmbH, a Partner System Integrator (PSI) of Cognex. Their system solution demonstrated an advanced approach which convinced those responsible at BMW.

Timing and traceability

Measurement parameters had to be determined and then checked quickly and efficiently without interrupting production.  The timing frequency of the production line determined the time available for testing, and the complete testing system for the head-up display had to, of course, prove financially viable by functioning within a predefined time-frame and coping with the corresponding numbers of vehicles. The testing system had to be suitable for both left-side and right-hand steering.  An additional requirement meant that the testing system of the HUD also would need to be fully traceable and embedded into the information infrastructure of the entire corporate network.

Precise and impartial

Ultimately, the testing system of the HUD has to provide an objective result regarding quality, evaluating and assessing with much greater precision and reliability than the user. It was already clear in the feasibility study and during project planning, that this could only be handled with a PC-based high performance image processing system. Efficient hardware was required, and the algorithms of the vision software would be demanded to function with utmost reliability and precision.

No jams or standstills are tolerated on BMW’s two-shift assembly lines. The complete image acquisition- and- evaluation process of 50 acquired test images must be completed within a time-frame of less than two minutes.

The complete testing-equipment has to be swung into the vehicle as production is in progress, positioned exactly, secured in place, and then needs to be removed from the vehicle again. This means a time-slot of approximately 30 seconds for image acquisition and image processing calculations in the test-cycle.

Cognex PC-based vision systems: the highest degree of reliability

The wide range of visual qualities of the projected virtual images make the evaluation of the images considerably more difficult. Image processing cannot however be a cause for error in quality control under changing environmental production conditions. This includes, among other issues, the problem-subject “contrast of displays” under varying conditions of illumination.

Vision tools from the CVL (Cognex Vision Library) proved to be of great advantage. They provide interactive access to different programming levels, in-depth vision-software, including an option for a more precise detail-optimization. That is enabled the final solution –the selection of the tools, parameterization, linking and detail optimization –to be completed with a higher degree of safety and within a shorter development time.

Reliable detection in difficult conditions

Cognex vision tools perform to the highest of standards without compromising accuracy or safety. The most important individual features in the object image, such as edges, measurements, shapes, angles, bends and shades, are specifically and separately identified. The spatial conditions and relations between these central features of the acquired image are compared with the real-time image. The position of the object is then precisely determined according to this information.

Certain features can therefore be recognized at a considerably higher level of reliability, precision and speed. The influences of changing conditions of illumination and contrast are eliminated by a simultaneous investigation of the contour and the structure of the object image. These qualities proved to be of advantage in the detection of deformations and distortions of the HUDs. The functional safety of the vision tools also satisfied standards specified by BMW, which required it to be above 99%.

Meeting high standards

The image processing system must fulfill certain standards at BMW, and Cognex has for many years been among the suppliers who meet these requirements. The only real issue of interest is the reliable operation of the complete system. A stand-alone system could not be permitted on a globally parameterized production system. The most important issue for those working at the plant was that the image processing be fully and reliably integrated into the plant diagnosis system.

Long term traceability for customer satisfaction

The cooperation with Gefasoft proved to be of great benefit; the enterprise contributed greatly to the solution thanks to their flexibility and their capacity to react quickly within a limited schedule.  By 2004, the first head-up display testing systems were installed. The positive results of the operation resulted in the head-up display testing systems also being installed in the normal series production in the factory at Dingolfing. Today, approximately a dozen HUD testing systems are in operation for BMW around-the-clock, ensuring the faultless quality of the HUDs. The test results are stored in a database in the central server, thus providing for total traceability. The test-images are archived, and in case of customer requests, the flawless condition of the product at the time of delivery can be proven, even years later.

Related Customer Stories

> TNGO, a machine builder that has supplied luminance inspection machines to major Korean LED production facilities, has integrated the Cognex DataMan® 100X and 100S, as well as the In-Sight® Micro 1110...
> Without a doubt, the electronic devices we see in the market today are shrinking in size. Be it an MP3 player, a DVD recorder or a laptop computer, small and slim is the way to go. As such, the printe...
> A single misplaced wire in an airbag sensor connector has the potential to cause a fatality. A critical part of making sure the connector is assembled correctly requires verifying that the right color...
> Nantong Fujitsu-Electronics is a Chinese-Japanese joint enterprise, based in Nantong, Jiangsu Province, China. They specialize in integrated circuit (IC) packages and testing. Because the IC process m...

Machine Vision Product Guide

Learn about the entire Cognex family vision products

Introduction to Machine Vision

Learn the basics of machine vision to support inspection applications and improve production line results

Barcode Readers
Product Guide

Learn about the entire Cognex family of barcode readers